

There can be no question that the contents of this book will prove extremely controversial. Many people will be deeply shocked by the nature of Watson's statement. Many will no doubt prefer to reject it rather than surrender the beliefs of a lifetime. Others will at least regret that two of the great mysteries of crime are finally solved... An extraordinary document comes to light which for fifty years had been held on deposit by the bankers of the deceased John Herbert Watson MD - better known as Dr Watson. The document, ...
BrianE
Mar 30, 2008
If you can handle Holmes in less than stellar shape, that is -- and like that the author messes around with what could have been. Fun, entertaining and non-canonical.
bookishwench
Jul 21, 2007
I hated this book. Seemed the author would write anything shocking or sensational just to sell a book. Nobody is much in character. I wish I never bought it.